Available Homes: Island Living

These island homes are available as of June 27, 2025.

It's true! Yes, you can own an island just two hours from midtown Manhattan! 

Here are four properties currently available in the legendary Thimble Islands off the coast of Branford. Imagine your own island paradise within commuting distance of Times Square. Wake up to 360 degree views of Long Island Sound.  This could be your weekend itinerary: take the train from Grand Central Station to New Haven. Pick up your car at the station's parking garage. Pick up groceries at the Stop and Shop in Branford on your way to the marina where your Boston Whaler is moored. 10 minutes later you're on your island paradise for a weekend of relaxation, barbecues, cocktails and rest, a world away from the madness of Manhattan. 

BURR ISLAND - $1,050,000


BELDEN ISLAND
- $2,750,000



POTATO ISLAND
- $4,950,000

ROGERS ISLAND - $29,995,000

Thinking about a second or weekend home in Connecticut? I'm here to help. The search for a home is more than a transaction—it’s a journey, and I’d be honored to take it with you. Let's start with a visit. Hop on the train at Grand Central Station and two hours later I'll meet you in New Haven for an area tour. There's no better way to start.

Let’s talk.

David Mayhew, REALTOR®
Pearce Real Estate, 18 Church Street, Guilford, CT 06437
dmayhew@hpearce.com, call or text 203.533.5621
Licensed in the State of Connecticut #RES.0784723